European Court of Auditors (ECA) Special Report 24/2026: EU funding for innovation and competitiveness published
The report assesses the effectiveness of the European Union's Horizon 2020 (H2020) funding program—specifically its "industrial leadership" priority, which had a budget of approximately €17 billion (2014–2020). The audit evaluated whether this funding successfully supported innovation, technology transfer, market uptake, and the scaling-up of innovative companies, particularly SMEs.
Overall, the ECA concluded that while EU strategic priorities were adequately reflected in the program, the funding had a limited impact on bringing innovative products to market and scaling up businesses.
Key Findings
- Focus on Mid-Level Research over Close-to-Market Action: The program intended to help companies commercialize innovations. However, calls for funding heavily targeted mid-Technology Readiness Levels (TRLs)—meaning projects focused more on validation and demonstration rather than late-stage commercialization and scaling up. Only about half of the financial support under this priority went to close-to-market activities.
- Funding Concentrated on Non-Profits: Although for-profit entities (including SMEs) made up the majority of participants, about 50% of the actual funding went to non-profit organizations, research institutes, and universities. These entities often received a 100% funding rate, which weakened the program's ability to leverage private investment.
- Limited Leadership by SMEs: SMEs rarely acted as project coordinators in collaborative projects, which limited their control over project direction, intellectual property, and commercial exploitation. Furthermore, over a third of participating SMEs cited "networking" rather than actual innovation as their primary reason for joining.
- Flawed Selection and Assessment Criteria: The "impact" criterion was not used consistently during the selection process to identify projects with high economic or scale-up potential. The program also did not evaluate the existing "innovation capacity" of participants before awarding funds.
- Inadequate Monitoring and Evaluation: The European Commission failed to systematically track the long-term economic performance or innovation capacity of the participants after projects ended. Evaluators found that many SMEs significantly overestimated their potential economic gains (such as job creation or revenue) in their initial proposals, and the Commission lacked robust methods to assess lasting economic value.
Key Recommendations To improve the upcoming 2028–2034 Horizon Europe program and the new European Competitiveness Fund, the ECA recommends that the European Commission:
- Shift Focus to Market Entry: Prioritize funding for higher TRL (close-to-market) projects and design targeted funding schemes specifically for the market entry and scale-up of companies.
- Consistently Apply the "Impact" Criterion: Ensure that project selection strictly evaluates a proposal's commercial and scale-up potential.
- Enhance Support for SMEs: Improve measures that support technology transfer, dissemination, and the commercial use of project results, specifically empowering SMEs.
- Overhaul Monitoring Systems: Develop robust methods to track and assess the long-term economic performance, innovation capacity, and tangible market impact of the entities receiving EU research funding.
Further details can be found here: https://www.eca.europa.eu/en/publications/SR-2026-24